Toronto FC v New York City FC result

Full-time · Toronto FC 2–3 New York City FC

Major League Soccer · · BMO Field

Updated · refreshed continuously

Team pages: Toronto FC · New York City FC · Head-to-head

Toronto FC 2–3 New York City FC — New York City FC won this Major League Soccer match.

Match report, in numbers

The result

New York City FC won 3–2 at BMO Field in Major League Soccer on Sunday 12 May.

Toronto FC have scored in five consecutive matches.

The goals

New York City FC led 2–0 at half-time. The goals — New York City FC: Santiago Rodríguez (23’ pen), Malachi Jones (44’, assisted by Hannes Wolf) and A. Perea (77’, assisted by Hannes Wolf); Toronto FC: Federico Bernardeschi (55’) and R. Petretta (89’, assisted by Matthew Longstaff).

The numbers

Expected goals (xG) agree with the result: Toronto FC 1.64, New York City FC 2.06, from 16 shots to 10 (the provider’s expected goals for this match).

Discipline

The bookings — Toronto FC: Federico Bernardeschi (24’), S. Rosted (36’) and K. Long (53’); New York City FC: A. Martínez (29’), Malachi Jones (50’) and A. Perea (90+9’).

Who stood out

By TACTIX Impact for this match, Hannes Wolf (New York City FC) 10.1, Santiago Rodríguez (New York City FC) 8.6 and Federico Bernardeschi (Toronto FC) 8.0 led the match.

Next up

Toronto FC next travel to Columbus Crew on 24 October 2026.

New York City FC next travel to Orlando City SC on 24 October 2026.

Written from the matches TACTIX holds for both sides; each figure names the games it is counted over.

Next for Toronto FC: Columbus Crew v Toronto FC, Saturday 24 October — the preview. Next for New York City FC: Orlando City SC v New York City FC, Sunday 25 October — the preview.

The numbers

  • Result: Toronto FC 2–3 New York City FC · Major League Soccer
  • Venue: BMO Field · Toronto, Ontario
  • Referee: L. Szpala
  • Head-to-head (last 6): Toronto FC 2 · draws 0 · New York City FC 4 · 4 goals/game
  • Recent form: Toronto FC 3W 0D 2L · New York City FC 3W 1D 1L

Toronto FC 2–3 New York City FC (Major League Soccer): this fixture is settled. TACTIX’s pre-match coverage ran across every major market, and every graded call — wins and losses — is in the live track record (as of 8 May 2026). See the live track record →

Key stats

1.5 / 1.25
Goals
against 1.75 / 0.88 · 4 of the last 5 over 2.5
over 8 matches
4.43 / 4.71
Corners
against 5.29 / 4.57 · 2 of the last 4 over 9.5
over 7 matches
4.57 / 5.71
Shots on target
against 5.86 / 4.43 · 3 of the last 4 over 8.5
over 7 matches
3.57 / 1.71
Cards
against 2.43 / 2.71 · 4 of the last 4 over 3.5
over 7 matches

Per game, last 8 completed matches, to 5 May 2024. Over/under figures use standard thresholds, not bookmaker lines.

Per game, last 8 completed matches, to 5 May 2024. Bars: for (mint) against (amber), scaled to the larger figure in the row. Over/under figures use standard thresholds, not bookmaker lines.
Per gameToronto FC for / againstLineNew York City FC for / against
Goals scored
1.5 for · 1.75 against n 8
2.5standard
1.25 for · 0.88 against n 8
Corners won
4.43 for · 5.29 against n 7
9.5standard
4.71 for · 4.57 against n 7
Shots
13 for · 13.43 against n 7
19.5standard
15.43 for · 10.57 against n 7
Shots on target
4.57 for · 5.86 against n 7
8.5standard
5.71 for · 4.43 against n 7
Fouls committed
14.29 for · 11.86 against n 7
21.5standard
14.43 for · 13.43 against n 7
Cards shown
3.57 for · 2.43 against n 7
3.5standard
1.71 for · 2.71 against n 7

Referee: L. Szpala.

Toronto FC
Toronto FC — Discipline: per 90 minutes, each player’s last 8 appearances before kick-off, to 5 May 2024. Meter: one column per match, newest first; upper cell 1+, lower cell 2+.
PlayerMinsFouls committed 1+2+Fouls won 1+2+Likely duel
A. Akinola n 813.1
3.42/2
0.91/0
—
Prince Owusu n 863
3.27/6
0.94/1
—
S. Rosted n 875.8
2.27/4
0.32/0
—
Shane O'Neill n 875.6
2.16/3
0.63/1
—
C. Mailula n 851.8
25/3
26/2
—
Toronto FC — Shooting: per 90 minutes, each player’s last 8 appearances before kick-off, to 5 May 2024. Meter: one column per match, newest first; upper cell 1+, lower cell 2+.
PlayerMinsShots 1+2+Shots on target 1+2+
L. Insigne n 874.9
38/5
1.27/1
F. Bernardeschi n 891
2.87/5
1.65/3
A. Akinola n 813.1
2.62/1
00/0
C. Mailula n 851.8
1.55/2
0.73/0
Prince Owusu n 863
1.44/4
1.14/2
Toronto FC — Goalscoring: per 90 minutes, each player’s last 8 appearances before kick-off, to 5 May 2024. Meter: one column per match, newest first; upper cell 1+, lower cell 2+.
PlayerMinsGoals 1+2+Assists 1+2+
Prince Owusu n 863
0.94/1
00/0
Jahkeele Marshall-Rutty n 863.4
0.21/0
0.42/0
L. Insigne n 874.9
0.32/0
0.21/0
F. Bernardeschi n 891
0.21/1
0.22/0
Tyrese Spicer n 768.1
0.42/0
00/0
Toronto FC — Tackles: per 90 minutes, each player’s last 8 appearances before kick-off, to 5 May 2024. Meter: one column per match, newest first; upper cell 1+, lower cell 2+.
PlayerMinsTackles 1+2+
Alonso Coello n 866.3
3.67/6
K. Thompson n 826.8
3.45/3
D. Flores n 878.8
36/5
Matthew Longstaff n 853.6
2.57/4
Tyrese Spicer n 768.1
2.15/3
Toronto FC — Goalkeeper saves: per 90 minutes, each player’s last 8 appearances before kick-off, to 5 May 2024. Meter: one column per match, newest first; upper cell 2+, lower cell 3+.
PlayerMinsSaves 2+3+
Luka Gavran n 891
4.98/7
Sean Johnson n 890
36/3
New York City FC
New York City FC — Discipline: per 90 minutes, each player’s last 8 appearances before kick-off, to 5 May 2024. Meter: one column per match, newest first; upper cell 1+, lower cell 2+.
PlayerMinsFouls committed 1+2+Fouls won 1+2+Likely duel
Malachi Jones n 525.8
2.82/1
2.13/0
—
S. Tanasijevic n 359.3
2.52/2
1.51/1
—
J. Mijatović n 822.3
2.54/1
2.54/1
—
Justin Haak n 823.8
2.43/1
2.44/1
—
J. Sands n 891.4
2.18/5
1.86/5
—
New York City FC — Shooting: per 90 minutes, each player’s last 8 appearances before kick-off, to 5 May 2024. Meter: one column per match, newest first; upper cell 1+, lower cell 2+.
PlayerMinsShots 1+2+Shots on target 1+2+
M. Bakrar n 879.3
3.48/6
1.33/2
Santiago Rodríguez n 891.3
38/8
1.57/3
Julián Fernández n 839.5
2.86/4
1.74/2
A. Martínez n 830.9
2.65/2
1.53/1
Malachi Jones n 525.8
2.12/1
00/0
New York City FC — Goalscoring: per 90 minutes, each player’s last 8 appearances before kick-off, to 5 May 2024. Meter: one column per match, newest first; upper cell 1+, lower cell 2+.
PlayerMinsGoals 1+2+Assists 1+2+
Julián Fernández n 839.5
0.62/0
0.62/0
A. Martínez n 830.9
0.72/0
00/0
Santiago Rodríguez n 891.3
0.43/0
0.22/0
A. Jasson n 868.4
0.21/0
0.21/0
Keaton Parks n 881.9
0.11/0
0.11/0
New York City FC — Tackles: per 90 minutes, each player’s last 8 appearances before kick-off, to 5 May 2024. Meter: one column per match, newest first; upper cell 1+, lower cell 2+.
PlayerMinsTackles 1+2+
J. Sands n 891.4
3.18/6
A. Perea n 833.9
34/3
Malachi Jones n 525.8
2.84/0
A. Jasson n 868.4
2.55/4
Justin Haak n 823.8
2.45/0
New York City FC — Goalkeeper saves: per 90 minutes, each player’s last 8 appearances before kick-off, to 5 May 2024. Meter: one column per match, newest first; upper cell 2+, lower cell 3+.
PlayerMinsSaves 2+3+
Matthew Freese n 891.4
3.76/5

The day’s free picks, by email

Every morning at 07:30 UK: the model’s free picks, each with its confidence tier and that tier’s settled record, misses included. No tips, no guarantees, one click to leave.

Match statistics & details

Full-time team statistics as recorded by the data provider; – = not recorded.
Toronto FCNew York City FC
60%Possession40%
1.64Expected goals (xG)2.06
16Shots10
11Shots on target4
2Shots off target2
3Blocked shots4
12Shots inside the box5
6Corners4
2Offsides1
17Fouls13
3Yellow cards3
0Red cards0
1Saves9
520Passes341
85%Pass accuracy80%

Toronto FC player stats

PlayerMinGAShSoTKPTklCardsRating
Sean Johnson9900000006.5
Nickseon Gomis9900001306.5
F. Bernardeschi99103331Y8.3
Matthew Longstaff9901112407.2
Tyrese Spicer9900001306.9
Jonathan Osorio9900211207.2
Prince Owusu9900322307.5
K. Long79001100Y6.9
D. Flores7600000006.2
Derrick Etienne7600001106.9
S. Rosted67001102Y6.9
R. Petretta sub3210110107.3
Alonso Coello sub2300001206.9
L. Insigne sub2300110006.5
K. Thompson sub2000001107

New York City FC player stats

PlayerMinGAShSoTKPTklCardsRating
Matthew Freese9900000008.3
Tayvon Gray9900000206.6
Thiago Martins9900100106.7
B. Risa9900000106.3
Kevin O'Toole9900000206.5
J. Sands9900001506.9
A. Perea99101124Y7
Santiago Rodríguez9510210307.2
Hannes Wolf9002004307.6
Malachi Jones69102201Y7.3
A. Martínez69000000Y6.5
Keaton Parks sub3000000106.7
Agustin Ojeda sub3000001106.6
S. Tanasijevic sub900000006.3
A. Jasson sub40000010–

Sh = shots, SoT = shots on target, KP = key passes, Tkl = tackles; – = not recorded for that player. Rating is the data provider’s.

Form, head-to-head & standings

The numbers behind Toronto FC v New York City FC — recent results, past meetings and where each side sits. (TACTIX’s model forecast is in the projections below.)

Recent form
Toronto FCLLWWW
Last 5: 3W 0D 2L · 1.6 scored / 1.8 conceded per game
New York City FCDWWWL
Last 5: 3W 1D 1L · 1.4 scored / 0.8 conceded per game
Head-to-head last 6
Toronto FC 2 · 0 draws · New York City FC 4 · 4 goals/game
  • 2024-03-16 New York City FC 2–1 Toronto FC
  • 2023-09-24 New York City FC 3–0 Toronto FC
  • 2023-07-26 New York City FC 5–0 Toronto FC
  • 2023-04-29 Toronto FC 1–0 New York City FC
  • 2022-04-24 New York City FC 5–4 Toronto FC
  • 2022-04-02 Toronto FC 2–1 New York City FC
League standing · 2024
Last recorded position — not updated during the season.
Toronto FC#11 pos37 pts34 pl-21 GD
New York City FC#6 pos50 pts34 pl+5 GD
Goals per game
Toronto FC scored1.18
New York City FC scored1.59
Toronto FC conceded1.79
New York City FC conceded1.44

The full post-match picture

Pro members see this match shot by shot — every attempt with its expected-goals value, the situation and shot-type breakdowns, the xG timeline, and how the model’s pre-match probabilities compared with what happened. Plus every market the model graded for this fixture.

Try Pro for £1.00 — the full match analysis

£1.00 for 14 days, then £9.99/month. Cancel in the trial and pay nothing more.

Frequently asked questions

What is the head-to-head record between Toronto FC and New York City FC?
In their last 6 meetings, Toronto FC won 2, New York City FC won 4 and there were 0 draws, averaging 4 goals per game.
What is the recent form of Toronto FC and New York City FC?
Recent form — Toronto FC 3W 0D 2L; New York City FC 3W 1D 1L.

Today’s boards

Every fixture kicking off in the UK day, and the fixtures where the free pick leads with each market.

Predictions todayTomorrowBTTS boardOver 2.5 boardUnder 2.5 boardOver 1.5 boardHome win boardAway win boardDouble chance board
Share this prediction: X · Facebook · WhatsApp · Telegram

This page is generated from TACTIX’s match data by our software and checked automatically; data as of . How it works → · Report an error

How our model works · Live track record · Predictions are model output, not betting advice.

Unlock all predictions, advanced stats & value against the bookies with ProTry Pro for £1.00 →